The first 72 hours of a workplace investigation

What boards should do — and conspicuously not do — when a serious allegation lands on the general counsel's desk.

Nathan Cho · Lexline & Marlowe

Every investigation is won or lost before the first interview. The decisions made in the first three days determine the credibility of the process and, often, the outcome.

Do

  • Preserve first. Suspend routine deletion of messages and voicemails for the implicated custodians. Spoliation is the one unforced error that cannot be walked back.
  • Define the scope in writing. “Investigate the allegations” is not a scope. A defensible scope names the conduct, the period, and the custodians — and reserves the right to expand.
  • Decide who decides. The investigator reports to a named committee or officer. Ambiguity about who receives the report infects everything downstream.

Do not

  • Do not promise confidentiality you cannot keep. Promise process instead: what will be shared, with whom, and when.
  • Do not interview the complainant and respondent on the same day in the same room sequence.
  • Do not let the subject’s champion pick the investigator. Independence is not a preference; it is the product.

The report

A good investigative report reads like a record, not a brief: what was alleged, what was asked, what was said, and what was found — with the credibility reasoning that connects them.


This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Begin the conversation

Facing this question in your own matter?

A partner will review your situation and respond within one business day.

Prefer to speak now? +1 (212) 555-0184 — available 24/7 for urgent matters.