Earnouts after closing: drafting for the disputes you hope to avoid

Most post-closing earnout fights trace back to four drafting decisions. A framework for getting them right at the term sheet.

James Okafor · Lexline & Marlowe

The earnout is where deal lawyers earn their fees twice — once at signing, and again in the litigation that too often follows. In our experience, most post-closing disputes trace back to a handful of drafting decisions made under deadline pressure.

Four decisions that matter

  1. Define the metric in the seller’s own language. EBITDA calculated “consistent with past practice” invites a fight over what past practice was. Attach the historical computation as an exhibit.
  2. Control the business between signing and measurement. If the buyer can operate the acquired business “in its discretion,” the earnout is a discretionary bonus. Negotiate operating covenants with teeth.
  3. Give the seller audit rights that are usable. A right to audit “once, at seller’s expense, unless a discrepancy exceeding 5% is found” is standard — and often insufficient for businesses with lumpy revenue.
  4. Pre-agree the forum and the standard. Arbitration with an accountant-determination mechanism resolves 80% of earnout disputes at a fraction of litigation cost.

The term sheet is the leverage point

Every one of these protections is harder to obtain after definitive documents circulate. Raise them in the term sheet, when both sides are still solving problems together rather than assigning blame for them.


This article is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Begin the conversation

Facing this question in your own matter?

A partner will review your situation and respond within one business day.

Prefer to speak now? +1 (212) 555-0184 — available 24/7 for urgent matters.